SignalSnitchSignalSnitch
Head-to-head · graded accuracy

@keithmccullough vs @sentimentrader

Who's the more accurate trader? Both records graded against real market data on SignalSnitch — a backward-looking comparison, not financial advice.

Keith McCullough avatarKeith McCullough
@keithmccullough
37%
accuracy · 422 trades
Rank #194 overall
vs
SentimenTrader avatarSentimenTrader
@sentimentrader
34%
accuracy · 59 trades
Rank #192 overall

Head-to-head

Metric@keithmccullough@sentimentrader
Accuracy37%34%
Overall rank#194#192
Reliability score2929
Resolved trades42259
Wins15720
Losses26539
Trades (30d)16412
Followers393k268k
PlatformXX

Frequently asked questions

Is @keithmccullough or @sentimentrader more accurate?

@keithmccullough is graded 37% over 422 calls; @sentimentrader is graded 34% over 59 calls on SignalSnitch. By graded accuracy, @keithmccullough leads (37% vs 34%). On the overall leaderboard, @sentimentrader ranks higher (#192 vs #194). Both are backward-looking records, not financial advice.

How do @keithmccullough and @sentimentrader compare?

Head-to-head on SignalSnitch: @keithmccullough has 157 wins / 265 losses (rank #194), and @sentimentrader has 20 wins / 39 losses (rank #192). Every call is settled against real historical market data.

Should I follow @keithmccullough or @sentimentrader?

SignalSnitch doesn't recommend who to follow. We publish both graded track records side by side so you can compare accountability for yourself. This is data, not financial advice.

Updated July 11, 2026

See every trade outcome from both.

SignalSnitch settles every public trade from @keithmccullough, @sentimentrader, and thousands of other traders against real market data. Free to sign up.

Create free account →